lol none of them…

nayther one! I’, tired of Mimi dressin’ like that. She looks great but damn woman, you are 38 years old!

Mariah!!!

yawn

Dayum that dress Kelis has on is HOT!!!! I luv the colour & the design & detail. Very Hot & VERY Original. Kelis always does her thing to me. She rocks it like no one else. Dayum I miss her long curly hair!!! But, she’s Bossy…lol!!

Kelis dress looks home made and Mariah looks like she has no hips.

This is not the way to get the year started.

Kelis hands down!

Vanessa Simmons second.

Kelis hands down. Mariah looks so plain the contesst should have been between Kelis and Vanessa Simmons.

Damn Betty Crocker. So are you a gemini too?

Mariah’s man body needs to keep working that side pose w/that leg popped like she’s in a pageant. If it wasn’t for her boobs she’d be shaped like a linebacker.

*Spongebob Squarepants….

Kelis looks great!

Nice picture, “FyreStarrter”

Kelis of course, what you mean?

Damn I love me some Mariah.

Kelis actually looks pretty….I have to give it to her because she looks terrible to me most of the time.

uh! what in insult to Kelis. Mariah is a perpetual mess and Kelis is a queen of style. There’s not comparison

Kelis is da bomb. Can’t wait for new material from her and Mariah. Mariah needs a makeover.

Will somebody please tell Mariah that she is not a reincarnation of Marilyn Monroe?

She looked like a fool in the video doing the countdown to New Year’s.

@ Guilty Pleaure, thanks luv Carmine is one of the sexiest! And I HAVE to pay tribute to his sexiness!!! lol

@me888 I second that this comparison is DEFINITELY an insult to my gyrl Kelis. I just LUV her style!

@V THAT WAS FUNNY I AGREE SHE HAS A WEIRD SHAPE I GUESS I’LL GO WITH KELIS EVEN THOUGH I THINK NEITHER ONE DID THEY THING

I’d say Kelis…I think Mariah should change up her style from the typical tight short dress…it doesn’t compliment her.

KELIS IS LOOKING KINDA HOT. DONT THINK I EVER SAW HER LOOK LIKE THAT BEFORE. SHE USUALLY JUST LOOKS INCOMPLETE OR OVERDONE.

Was up Bird, naw I’m a Pisces

Mariah looks good; but the outfit is predictable. Kelis on the other hand, looks amazing and her outfits always keep you in awe.

Kelis looks amazing and is doing her thing.

MARIAH OUTFIT WAS TOO PLAIN. IT WAS A SAFE CHOICE THOUGH I GUESS SHE DIDNT WANT TO END UP ON A WORSE DRESSED LIST. HOWEVER, I WILL GIVE IT TO KELIS. I LOVE HER STYLE SO IS SO ORGINAL W/ EVERYTHING SHE DOES. SHE’S ALSO JUST TOO GORGEOUS. ESPECIALLY ON THE COVER OF KELIS WAS HERE .. GIRL’S HAIR AND MAKEUP WAS ON POINT. I THINK KELIS IS MODEL PRETTY. THAT SHE BE HER JUMP OFF CAUSE BESIDES NAS SHE NEED A WAY TO PAY SOME BILLS

@ LADY … I AGREE MARIAH NEEDS A NEW STYLIST. EVERYTHING SHE WEAR IS EITHER TIGHT, OR SHORT OR LOW CUT , OR ALL OF THE ABOVE. SHE GETTING TO OLD FOR THAT. SHE NEED TO CLASS UP HER IMAGE.

Mariah does look particuarly “STRONG” in this pic…like she’s bench presses houses and stuff…Kelis is always bringa unique flavour to whatever she dons….

Mariah of course. I LLLLOOOOOOOVEEEE Mariah, although like Ms Beyonce, she needs to go see an image consultant and hire a new stylist revamp her whole new look to the GROWN WOMAN catagory lol

And WHY is Nas standin there lookin’ like a derranged precher man??????

I can’t put my finger on it but something is definately OFF about dude in that picture.

Don’t tell me Kelis and her weirdness are starting to get to him….NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

Kelis looks good as hell! (Just don’t like how the side of the dress is sticking out!) But everything else looks great!

I love everything about Kelis’ dress; the color the style, it’s hot. Mariah looks nice too, but in comparison to Kelis, Mariah is not filling out her dress. So definitely Kelis.

KELIS IS BANGING! DAMN. The dress looks like something out of ‘Posse’, made into a mini, but Kelis herself looks fantastic.

Mimi gets points off for having fake tits.

I like Kelis’dress. It’s different & pretty.

Kelis looks gorgeous in that last pic with Dania. Yellow suits her and I love the black bob.

I too usually think Kelis looks a mess but she looks cute here.

Kelis did it!! Mariah looks good too…

i say kelis. mariah needs to start dressing her age. what is she, like 50 now?

Something looks quite different about Kelis face. Has she had some work done or something?

Kelis wins hands down. Mariah is getting wider all the time, her boobs look entirely too fake and spread apart and her skin ain’t on one accord color wise…she looks speckled. And Diana Ramirez is wrong for that gettup lookin like she let Solange dress her!…where is solange’s hubby these days…..

I went back to double check….Kelis still got it. Mariah looks like an OLD GO-LIVER!

KELIS ALL DAY. MIMI ALWAYS LOOK LIKE SHE SMUGGLIN HUNGRY PUPPIES IN HER TOP

KELIS! Cause she switched it up you always gotta give credit to the person who tries something different and it ends up working. And thats what Kelis did. She’s a fashionista. But Mariah is prettier.

KELIS!!

im the biggest mariah fan but kelis got her on this one…that outfit is so flyyy! mimi really over did the boob job, she looks too top heavy…

Fyrestarter, if that is your picture, I gotta say you are cute as hell! I choose you! Heyyy!

Ms. Kelis

Kelis wins it.

Mariah always looks so top-heavy in those annoying, clingy mermaid dresses. MiMi please learn to leave something to the imagination, and stay out of the sun it’s causing you to crack all up in your eye area.

Kelis her style is always her own. Now as for Mimi, she needs to style in her own age group. I’m still wondering why she was trying to be Britney Spears double on the New years. She looked like an over age wide mess. That two piece was whoriffic.

I like them both, but they both look CRAZY!!!!!!!

On this one Mariah is hotter than chili pepper!!!!!

No contest, Mariah with the Golden Vagina. Kelis looks like the black version of LUCY of I LOVE LUCY.

Kelis got that hands down!!!

I seriously <3 that women

Are you kidding?? KELIS LOOKS EXTRA FIERCE!! I LOVE HER HAIR SHORT AND JET BLACK AND THAT YELLOW LOOKS FABULOUS ON HER! DO YO THANG MAMA!!

Kelis got that and Nas’ attire if FIRE!!!!

I am SOOOO TIRED of this look of Mariah’s. Really folks, change the color and shoes, and it’s the SAME DRESS you’ve seen a1000 times. And don’t get me started over that tired Butterfly…. Someone call a Macy’s personal shopper!

Kelis.

LMAO @ Trixie!

what in the hell is up with that dam lipstick yuck!!!!!!!!!

kelis is fierce!

What happened to Mariah? Did she get turned out?

All she does is wear short dress/skirts and show off those big fake tities?

Cover up girl; you’ll look less despirate !

Kelis got this one, she looks good and looks upto date with “todays” fashion. Mariah looks sooo 80′s, its time for a major change. The Simmons girl is just another bandwagoner with the hair everyone trying to imitate Rhianna’s hairstyle.

Kelis looks more interesting, I actually like the dress, and Mariah’s dress looks a little too tight.