Poor Whitney. First

I hear her CD was OK

those crack fumes do some serious damage, she’s still healing!! lay off whitney she’s gettin back ont the right track!

So what. Most of these manufactured singers can’t even to lip-synch properly.

I LOVE YOU, WHITNEY!

@medievalpoetry Shut your ugly A$$ UP….

All the best to Whitney. I’m waiting for that new Mariah album though

WHITNEY WILL ALWAYS BE GREAT. NEVER GET IT TWISTED. MARIAH OK BUT THIS IS ABOUT WHITNEY. IF YOU WANT MARIAH GO TO HER WEB PAGE OR JUST STFU

Welcome Back !! Whitney !!!

Whitney went through hell and back. She took a long time off to get herself together and look at her now. I am so proud of her. What an amazing lady!

ITS WHITNEY……SHE CAN HAVE A SLIP UP…….

FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER :http://twitter.com/HArl3Mw1lDCH1ld
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER :http://twitter.com/HArl3Mw1lDCH1ld
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER :http://twitter.com/HArl3Mw1lDCH1ld
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER :http://twitter.com/HArl3Mw1lDCH1ld
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER :http://twitter.com/HArl3Mw1lDCH1ld

i feel sorry for her, but thankfully, she’s made enough quality music that she’ll never have to work again……atleast I don’t think she will

I used to like Whitney…Pre-Bobby Brown Whitney. I hate how we are suppose to love her again and accept her just cause she’s Whitney.She needs to prove that she is making a REAL change. I wont spend a dime on her CD knowing its going to crack.

the entire performance was bad, I LOOK TO YOU was horrible.

Gladys Knight can still sing, Patti can still sing..what has happen to Whitney, Mariah?

Chante Moore can still sing, Tamia can still sing.

sad, that our legends are just bodies with weave, make up and high heels and the voices have faded

I do love Mariah’s remake of I want to know what love is, she sounds good on that, very pretty

Actually she did a 3 hour interview with Oprah the day before and she was already feeling under the weather. So, I give her a pass on this. Definitely looking fwd to seeing the interview on Monday 9/14.

I just saw the perfermance & it’s official. Whitney has ruined her God given voice. If she never smoked another pipe or cigaratte, I don’t think she could get it back. Why did she sing “My Love is Your Love”? That wasn’t even one of her big hits. She spend about 5 mins alibing the end while bringing out Bobbi Christina. Them people didn’t not stand out there all night to see your daughter. She could have gone into a melody of hits. The band looked embarrassed for her. I doubt if she tours. Whit fake 15mins on GMA. She can’t fake 2hrs, 3 nights a week.

FAIL!!!! GIVE UP OLD LADY! THE 80′S AND 90′S ARE OVER!!!!

It’s them Newports.

*still…not stick

I wish her the best, she has been through hell and back,, Keep your head up girl

@ M DOT
Actually she did a 3 hour interview with Oprah the day before and she was already feeling under the weather. So, I give her a pass on this. Definitely looking fwd to seeing the interview on Monday 9/14.
***********
I-co sign. I can’t wait for her interview with Oprah.

We’ll never get the “You Give Good Love” Whitney back, but even after the drugs, this Whitney still sounds better than almost everything out there.

Got her new cd..Hmmm It’s Ok

LOL @medievalpoetry up there lookin’ like a Milli Vanilli mix

The fall of an ICON

Whitney is finished. She can sell number one all she wants. She can’t tour to support the music. She should do a lecture tour about saing NO to drugs.

@LOvely

@medievalpoetry Shut your ugly A$$ UP….

——————————-
you made me choke on my soda!

SO WHAT ID RATHER HEAR HER VOICE THAN THAT STANKIN BYTCH RHI,RHI.., DA ROBOTIC SOUNDING HO…WHITNEY IZ STILL THE BIZNESS CRAKHEAD VOICE AND ALL….WE LOVE YOU WHIT !

To me it seems like the background singers & the audiences were doing more of singing than Whitney! LMAO Nice try, Whitney…

I don’t want to seem cruel or disrespectful, but she did not sound too good this morning, at least by her “old” standards. She failed to even hit certain mid-range notes. And when she did, her voice cracked. She seemed to not be in tune with the music several times during the performance. She also appeared to lack the vocal stamina to sing for an entire song as she attempted to fill time with audience participation and her own dancing. The world has lost a truly great voice. BTW, for those who do not know, almost anyone can sound great on a CD after the studio ‘tweeks’ the vocals. Singing live is the test.

Sup Glok!

Yall are killing me in this thread. The same people in here praising her for this horrible mess were all over Mariah for the MJ Tribute. In my opinion neither one of them should be on stage anymore…just release studio efforts and call it a day.

and Yall stop wearing your blinders. You can’t criticize one and then praise the other…they were both TERRIBLE.

do it Whitney!!!

SHE STILL SOUNDS BETTER THEN RIHANNA THAT GOAT!!!!

Whoever made that comment about how Mariah is on top of her game.Are u serious? Mariah has been having really awful performances for the longest period.

Bobby did it.

TMHESQ!
WHAT UP CUZIN!

Ok, so she is not quite up to live performances yet. She has been down a long, hard road and may need a little more time.

I am a Whitney fan, so I am still getting the CD.

@ Glok. Nothin’ bro, just checkin in.
You know, Whitney may have had one of the top 5 voices America ever produced and it’s kinda tough to see her fall off so publicly.

@ Glok, I agree that she was the Biz.

I heard that concert and she did not sound that bad. She is just out of shape.

Stick a fork in her she done.

As to Mariah, at least she still look good.

I’ve always been a Whitney fan but truth be told that was not good at aaaall! Voice was hoarse, she’s making the audience sing most of it, changing keys throughout. She shoulda just said no (Crack is Wack)!!

Wow yall, this time I have nothing to say.

I kept listening hoping to hear the “old Whitney” but the “spark” has rusted. I hope she can get it back. This performance was “lack-luster” to say the least. She tried, bless her heart…..

SMOKING CRACK CAN HAVE A HORRIBLE EFFECT ON YOUR VOICE!!

OH YEAH SHE LOOKED GREAT!

Whitney. Give it up, u have more than enough to live on your reputation alone, write songs, produce, DO SOMETHING ELSE!!!! the singing is DONE.

The concert should have been postphoned until she was feeling better. I won’t judge her comeback based on one performance where she was hoarse. I look forward to her doing great things!

Give this woman a pass, please. She was on the brink of DEATH with her drug abuse. Be happy that the sister is out of the gutter, and trying to rebuild her life. MUCH LOVE TO YOU, WHIT-WHIT! Get ‘em, girl!

Lol her story; I just knew that Whitney was gonna deliver. My new born was asleep till she hit that extremely unflattering high note and she gave my baby nightmare he was actually crying in his sleep till she finished lol

Seriously all the hate is unnecessary. Give the woman a break. Considering all that she has been through she sounds and looks great.

That was awful. Why do you guys keep saying Mariah cant sing are you serious???? 18 number ones. Whitney looks old and sounds awful

I meant “choked up”

I will be buying her cd this weekend,,, as long as Whitney is true to herself God will continue to bring her thru and her voice back,God is! I love you Whitney

ms jazz

God said don’t attach my name to this bullshit

@ Charles, I agree that singers can damaage their voices. I knew a former professional who did just that. In fact, some female opera singers refuse to sing certain songs (arias, I believe) for fear of such damage because they are written to be sung at such a high level. BTW, this is why I give extra kudos to Aretha Franklin when she sung “Ave Maria” as a last minute replacement on an award show (check out Youtube for the clip).

Correction: Aretha sung “Nessun Dorma”

@ Charles:

I don’t meant to hate, BUT “Christina Aguilera” can sing rings around Whitney right about now…..

maybe she was nervous?? IDK…

@ bobbi

maybe she was nervous?? IDK…
______________________________________________________

DOUBTFUL…WHITNEY HAS SUNG AT PACKED COLISEUMS BEFORE, SANG THE NATIONAL ANTHEM, AND WASN’T “NERVOUS”….AS A SEASONED “VET”, SHE WOULDN’T HAVE GOTTEN NERVOUS UNLESS SHE KNEW SHE WAS FALTERING…..

WHITNEY HOUSTON/MARIAH CAREY = LEGENDS.

Without Whitney/Mariah there would be no RiRI or beyonce or Keri Hilson.

Mariah Carey and Whitney houston broke down racial barriers to become the two biggest selling female artist in HISTORY.

In the HISTORY BOOKS.

Have some respect. Last time we all checked the only perfect human was jesus.

Whitney and mariah deserve some respect.

thank you

Let’s hope she sells enough albums to keep the mortgage(s) paid!

@ daywalker

how dare you compare AN icon LIKE WHITNEY OR MARIAH WITH

…………………christina aguilera who got her start singing Mariah/Toni Braxton/whitney songs.

She’s a copycat. No original. Yes she’s talented but she has gotten raspy also vocally…it’s just a matter of time.

and shes arrogant.

Whites embrace their former misfits… you would never hear them say anything bad about Brittany ( she is back in the biz & going hard). Whitney needs support… so get with it you all.

I’m still pulling for ya Whitney. Shake it off!!!!

“SHANIA TWAIN” WAS MY TYPO AT Sep 2, 2009 – 1:17 pm

Ummmmmm….

I’m still pulling for ya Whitney. Shake it off!!!!
______________________________________________________

WASN’T THAT A MARIAH CAREY SONG??? WELL DON’T LET MISSY HEAR YOU SAY THAT, BECAUSE APPARENTLY IF IT’S BEEN DONE BEFORE IT DON’T COUNT…

So wonderful to see her back. She looked great, worked the crowd like the diva she is, and gave her all. Can’t wait for the tour. Her album will dominate the Grammys next year.

MARIAH MARIAH MARIAH. Every single time there is a Whitney article with bad press. People try and bring Mariah into it to take some heat off Whitney. What did this “Whitney performance” have to do with Mariah? People are just so pissed and done know how to take it. So they blame other artist. So sad. The MJ performance. WOW. Was Whitney there. Is this the topic? Grow up kids. Stop hating on Mariah. She has done nothing wrong to Whitney she always supports. So why are her fans bashing Mariah?

NOT TOO GOOD HER AND MARIAH GOT STEP THEIR PERFORMANCE GAME UP.

@ DAYWALKER AKA DIVA HOMO

YO SHUT UP.

WHITNEY HOUSTON AND MARIAH CAREY WERE PLAYED BY MY MOMS AND SISTERS FOR YEARS

CHRISTINA AGUILERAIEA OR WHATEVER HER NAME IS, ISN’T EVEN AN HONROABLE MENTION. SHE SOME LIL WHITE GIRL/MIXED SPANISH CHICK WALKING AROUND TRYIN TO SOUND LIKE “OUR QUEENS”

SHE WILL NEVER HAVE A CAREER LIKE MARIAH OR WHITNEY

EVER

HER FLAME IS BLOWN OUT, WITH HER BIG RASPY MAN SOUNDING VOICE

MARIAH AND WHITNEY ARE FOREVER BRO.

NOW GO DRESS UP LIKE WHITNEY LIKE YOU DO

@gmommy

I agree with you.

@ JAKE

@ DAYWALKER AKA DIVA HOMO

YO SHUT UP.

WHITNEY HOUSTON AND MARIAH CAREY WERE PLAYED BY MY MOMS AND SISTERS FOR YEARS

CHRISTINA AGUILERAIEA OR WHATEVER HER NAME IS, ISN’T EVEN AN HONROABLE MENTION. SHE SOME LIL WHITE GIRL/MIXED SPANISH CHICK WALKING AROUND TRYIN TO SOUND LIKE “OUR QUEENS”

SHE WILL NEVER HAVE A CAREER LIKE MARIAH OR WHITNEY

EVER

HER FLAME IS BLOWN OUT, WITH HER BIG RASPY MAN SOUNDING VOICE

MARIAH AND WHITNEY ARE FOREVER BRO.

NOW GO DRESS UP LIKE WHITNEY LIKE YOU DO
_____________________________________________________

SORRY, I’DON’T DRESS UP LIKE WOMEN, BUT I’M SURE YOUR BOYFRIEND DOES…GET MAD AND CALL ME GAY ALL YOU WANT, I KNOW I’M NOT, BUT DON’T GET MAD AT ME BECAUSE YOU TEND TO IGNORE FACTS!!! THE TRUTH IS THE TRUTH….WHITNEY WILL NEVER BE AS BIG AS MARIAH, AND CHRISTINA AGULIERA SOUNDS BETTER THAN WHITNEY THESE DAYS… LIVE WITH IT…..

@ soldiergirl:

YEP, I FORGOT ABOUT PINK, SHIRLEY MANSON FROM GARBAGE, CYNDI LAUPER AND TINA MARIE…ALL THESE WHITE GIRLS CAN BLOW, AND I DON’T MEAN THAT IN A SEXUAL WAY, EITHER!!!

I am trying to figure out why people think she is clean & sober. I never heard Whitney say that. People assume cause she has a CD coming out. She was still acting crackish this morning. Whitney lost her pipe partner but I doubt if she is completely sober.

Alright, alright. I just read many of the previous posts and most of them have good points.I was VERY disappointed in Whitney’s performance- like damn, I woke up for this??!! I just knew she was gonna bring it. Especially since this is supposed to be her “comeback.” What I’ve heard off of I Look to You doesn’t sound bad. But, after today’s performance I wonder how much was this project enhanced. I’m sure alot of these singers CDs are “enhanced.” But Whitney is/was the truth and I hate to even think of her voice and enhancement in the same thought!!! I think we will never hear the Whitney from the early 80′s, nor the Bodyguard Whitney ever again for that matter. Her management team or whomever decides when she’ll perform should have pushed back Oprah and GMA. I was embarrassed for her. And I wonder what caused the tears from her mom? Was she just happy to see her baby on stage trying? Or was she sad because she knows THE TRUTH. It is what it is. Whitney is not ready to perform…not now

@ Della: that was impressive. If this was just two years ago, I don’t see how she could have lost her voice so quickly, as others have said, unless she had a significant medical issue with her voice. I did notice that she didn’t complete a high note at the end of the song. Perhaps that was an indication of a pending or impending problem.

why black people always find a way to mess up their lives………..she was doing so well……I notice she lost her voice a long time ago since the time she perform at the awards and had to pass the mic over to one of her family or family friend.

Has anyone on here making these negative comments about Whitney ever made millions with their voice. If she did lose her voice at least God her a voice, to lose. So your opinion ain’t worth nada.

@ ACE

ACE UR STUPID. MARIAH CAREY IS THE NBR 1 SELLING FEMALE ARTIST IN HISTORY BEHIND BARBARA STREISAND. WHITNEY HOUSTON IS NBR 8. WTF ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT

ARE U ON CRACK?

MARIAH CAREYS IN JAPAN WORSHIP HER LIKE THEY DID MICHAEL JACKSON.

WHITNEY’S FANS HAVE SPLIT, SOME WENT WITH MARIAH, SOME WITH MARY J, SOME WITH BEYONCE, SOME WITH THE OLDER LADIES.

I have loved whitney since i was 9. i have supported her thru the awards, thru bobby, thru coke, thru the bad wigs and i’m so let down.

this is not a comeback, it really isn’t the cd is so-so. when has whitney ever made a so-so cd. her vocals are uninspired and the song choices are blah.

This is whitney houston, she deserves the high end songs (because she can’t write), the good producers, the best ballads.

what we get is luckwarm material, an unrehearsed bad GMA perfomance, and just a smidgen of the woman she use to be.

very sad day for me. Whitney i mess you.

about mariah carey, i went to her show and the woman SANG her heart out. what happens on these shows is her voice is not rested. on that mimi tour the chick killed it vocally. i like her.

LAUGHING SO HARD AT CHRISTIA’S BAD SINGING

If Whitney is even half as wonderful as she looks, I’m happy for her. Singing in the voice we’re accustomed to hearing may no longer be an option for her but if she’s healthy and spiritually well, that’s what matters most.

christina cracked bad LMAO

What makes people think Whitney is CLEAN & SOBER?

Sharon,
Those two you speak of let Hwood get to them, the game is a little diff, these ladies were not just r&b they were pop. Once ytou get to a certain level if you are not strong you are not going to make it. Her voice is gone, gone. I do think that she may be able to rework her voice but the range and power is no longer there. At least she came out of what she came out of, but who knows… what is next. The others you mentioned were not on drugs or huge pop stars with mental / drug issues.

So sad. I think Whitney’s true voice is gone for good. Beyond whatever damage her drug use did, I think hoarseness in older age runs in her family. If you’ve heard her Mom or Dionne Warwick sing in the last 10+ yrs., you know what I’m talking about. Both of their voices are FAR gone and I say this as someone who thinks Whitney may have been THE greatest ever in her prime. Now, even R. Kelly sounds 10x better singing ‘I Look To You’ on the spot. If you doubt, check the youtube.

Christina cracked, BUT…at least she sang the WHOLE SONG. Whitney, on the other hand, couldn’t get through NONE of those songs on GMA by herself. The audience sang more than she did!

Cmon guys lets be honest Clive Davis wanted this album to be a comeback album, what he should have did is contacted Mariah and asked her how to properly construct a comeback album, say what you want The Emancipation Of Mimi probably was one of the best comebacks in music period, and if you listen to it she gave her all on that album.. I love whitney but my problem is, that whitney doesn’t write, and when constructing a comeback one of the biggest things is getting your experiences out of it, I believe Brandy’s Human didn’t sell because of that, how do you guys feel? Do you think that maybe mariah should have helped write

I still don’t get the concept of some musicians not writing their own songs. I just doesn’t make sense to me. Mariah Carey’s next title song “I Want to Know What Love Is”, was sung by the group Foreigner, but was written by Mick Jones. Mariah, does some kinda whisper singing at the beginning of the song. But towards the middle and end, she manages to bring it together. I just can’t wait to hear her perform it LIVE.

I feel ya i can’t wait to hear it live as well, its a nice song, and i give Mariah a break, because at least all of her hits but one, has been written by her so thats great too me, i wish whit the best!!

@ Just…sing the d*mn song!!

Mariah is known as being a hell of a singer and songwriter. You can count on one hand the number of songs that Mariah has recorded that she didn’t write or produce and the majority of them were remakes like “I Want to Know What Love Is” by Foreigner and “The Beautiful Ones” by Prince.

It’s Whitney Houston and that’s all I have to say!

mariah sold more albums and got the most hits as a solo artist so i’ll give her a pass

@ KENDRA Thanks for throwing that in there for me, people who don’t really know mariah doesn’t know how talented she really is, she barely ever makes remakes, and when she does she normally makes beautiful ones, i think this will be a big hit for her

Oh gimme a break!!!!

Of course, Whitney’s voice is not how it used to be. Even without the drug use, TIME has a way of diminishing any songstress cords coupled with the fact that ANY SINGER WORTH THEIR WEIGHT IN GOLD KNOWS YOU SOUND DIFFERENT OUTSIDE THEN IN—REVERB ALONE WILL MAKE THE DIFFERENC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Plus–Didn’t she just finish recording on Oprah???

Instead of condemning this woman and comparing her voice to Mariah (which you can tell she doesn’t sing like she used to, either) why is it so hard to lift her up and commend her from coming back from the addiction pits of hell and attempting to reestablish herself???!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DAMN!!!!!!!!!!

Well, it’s nice to see Whitney has not broken her record of ongoing shitty live performances.

Why all the hate people?….This is someone’s mother…someone one’s daughter!!!….None of this negates her talent and all of her accomplishments. Whitney is and always wil be a legend….PERIOD!!!!!

Idk y all yall r on here talking about Mariah and her voice!!! If I recall correctly, she sounded a DAMN mess at the MJ memorial! She needs to sit down and put on some clothes; out here trying to compete (physically) with Beyonce and Rihanna! All her music sounds alike and I wish she would act her age for a change!

I want to support Whitney, only because I could hear snippets of her used to be great voice, she and Mariah need to move over Jennifer Hudson is in town!!!

All I know is I aint goin to NO Whitney concert if she gonna have me singin half the song cause she cant hit half the notes, i’m content with the CD thanks…take notes kiddies Crack is Wack