Why Usher?
He is a weak vocalist.
El DeBarge, Al B. Sure, James Ingram and Barry White on the original.
I guess Usher is filling the Al B. Sure role.

Meet genuine successful, independent men who want to share their success and wealth with an attractive, sophisticated lady at S e e k i n g A f f l u e n t c O m

some songs can’t be remade and this is one of them. This has nothing on the original.

Shouldn’t have switched up the beat and I didn’t even hear Robin Thicke

This is some special type of awwwwwful

I truly hope Tevin Campbell is making a comeback, if he is “we” meaning black folks need to support that. We are to good at berating and breaking each other down. We need to up lift one another.

USHER SOUNDS GREAT!!!!

Ok…..started off really good until the up tempo part came on….I stopped as soon as that part came on… couldn’t listen anymore…. Why would u f u c k up a perfectly good song like that????D A M N Shame

Not good at all. Leave quality things alone. That was some garbage!

This is a no, no and wrong on so many levels. You can’t improve or remake perfection. These artists are talented, but they did not do this song justice. I truly hope to NEVER hear this song EVER again.

Where did they find Tevin Campbell?? lol But it sounds good, but the original was better.

USHER IS BLACK AND THE BEST!

Robin pls stop to kill black music and stfu!!!

original black music are the best!!!

Should’ve had Remy Shand on this track!!! WTH happened to Tvin Campbell!? He looks like a mess in that pic LOL
Compared to the original, its a FAIL!!!

[...] [...]

Tevin Campbell? I heard from another site that Trey Songz was supposed to be on the remake?

Oh well… personally I think they should have left the original one alone. It sounds better…

USHER sounded GREAT!! I didn’t know R.T. could go the low, wow what a change, he should make more music sounding like that. Can we talk about Tevin C. his voice hasn’t changed a bit…still sounding like a wounded bird…wow! It would have been much better if they didn’t have that up tempo beat..should have been nice a slow like the original!

i like the idea…as long as diddy doesn’t show up on the re-mix I am alright with it.

Why????Why not leave well enough alone???? Good God…what not enough original material out there? So sad…even in the theatre ..do we really need anymore Jason/Freddie remakes? Please someone with some fresh original talent please stand up!

WHY DO YOU PEOPLE GIVE ROBIN THICKE PROPS IN THE R&B WORLD AND THEN TURN YOUR BACKS ON A TRUE TALENT LIKE TEVIN BECAUSE OF HIS SEXUAL PREFERENCE?????? TEVIN IS THE ONLY TRUE SINGER ON THIS TRACK AND HELL USHER’S GAY TOO AND ROBIN THICKE IS A DRUG HEAD SO GO FIGURE..

This is whack A booty shaking Secret Garden? With no Barry White baritone. Usher has peaked.

MODELS WANTED w w w internetmodeling.com/1341

WHYYYYYYYYY? LEAVE IT ALL ALONE MAN…

wtf was this s#!+?? my ears bled a lil bit. smh.

@chrishawn bellway…..i agree completely,Tevin can sing rings around Usher and Robin thick

can you bring me the original please.

I guess the industry is scrambling because folks are over the garbage and want “real” music and talent again. There is no way those of us that LOVE “real” music will support this mess. I truly hope Tevin comes out with something soon, he’s extremely talented. Plus, I am sure we will get original music from him. I just heard a nice song by Tony Terry the other day, I really need for these guys to come back.

I must admit, this version had to grow on me. I think the tempo is a little too fast but after a second take, I really like it. Glad to hear from Tevin again….good blend of voices.

accessindie.com/wordpress
4/19/10, 09:38:am
I guess the industry is scrambling because folks are over the garbage and want “real” music and talent again. There is no way those of us that LOVE “real” music will support this mess. I truly hope Tevin comes out with something soon, he’s extremely talented. Plus, I am sure we will get original music from him. I just heard a nice song by Tony Terry the other day, I really need for these guys to come back.
__________________________________________________________
I so agree! I’m so tired of Gay Songz..

It’s aight, but not as good as the original.

Sorry, but certain songs you just don’t remake.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

This is garbage. You don’t mess with perfection and this doesn’t even touch the original. You will never get singers like El, Barry, and James again…NEVER!

I’m soooo glad Telvin is on this track..He sounds great.. don’t care too much for the remake track

Now dat was just plain ol horrible!!

Well I know I like that song – I’ll have to listen to their version later, when I can.

One word….WHY?????

This is garbage!

They took this song and shredded it to pieces. You can never replace the deep sultry voice of Barry White. Had they kept it at the slow tempo it may have come out better.

AWW NAW THEY CANT DO IT LIKE THE SONIC BOOM OF THE SOUTH JACKSON STATES VERY OWN BEST BAND IN THE LAND..WE BE CLOWNING!! FALL 09 HELL YEA!! SECRET GARDEN.YOUTUBE THAT “SONIC BOOM OF THE SOUTH”

Tevin still sounds great!!!

This is Great,Old School

This verson should’ve never been released to general public.. NEVER..

I love it!

Sounds like they used a casio keyboard and old fashioned recorder..

It’s not that bad. I still like the slow original version though. Tevin Campbell still sound good. I hope he’s doing something with his talent. All the guys did a good job. I will like to hear it in it’s original version.

Are they serious with that ghost town DJs beat.. ugh. Terrible.. I cant stop laughing

@ErycaK: U said it all right there! The over the top vocals at the end and that whack casio beat killed it for me. Male versions of Bey at the end. Damn folk….damn!

I Like it….and Tevin sounded really good

It’s not that bad after a couple of listens but the tempo should NOT have been sped up. Yuk! And like someone said using ghostowns beat lol, just makes it sound dated!

And WTH??? Is that really Tevin Campbell on the right lol. Wow

Where in the hell is Robin Thicke?!? I heard Usher (ehh, 50\50 job) and Tevin Cambell (yes Lawd!).

Ahemmmm NO! Just simply,…NO!

It’s okay still, but it’s not as good as the original!!!!!

Sounded like someone was trying to channel a little Michael Jackson on the second part. Eh Whatever.

they should add this singer name Justin Garner to it!! he would sound sooooo good on this!!

Vocals are good. Production is a mess. What’s up with the techo speed beat? It’s like 2 different tracks in one. SLOW IT BACK DOWN!!!

@ NICNAQ

ROFL @ Ghost Town DJ’s beat. I actually busted out laughing.

Ok who the hell said it would be a good idea to speed up the tempo? STUPID. I will not be illegally downloading this version. Hopefully there will be a slower remix. Dam Tevin Campbell was talented. Hopefully he can come back less gay.

Exactly, speeding up the tempo “DESTROYED” the song…..Original much much better!! Stop messing up Original’s with this jive stuff, LOL.

FAIL FAIL FAIL!!!!!!!!

I’m pretty much in agreement with everybody here. They sung the song (obviously not as well as the originals) well but the 808′s. That’s some throwback ATL-style for you. Ironically, If you played Ghosttown DJs in the A today most of the people wouldn’t even know what the hell it was.

I like the original waaay better but, I will give this a chance. Not really feeling this tempo for the song. This originally is a sensitive song for intimacy and love making. Now, these three messed up the mood of the song so, the original chemical make-up of the song is basically distorted. The tempo and the lyrics don’t go together and that’s not cool. But they tried. Some things should not be revamped and “Secret Garden” is one of them along with “We are the World.”

I recognized the Gost Town DJs beat but that was back in our day. Good times.

I hate to admit this, but, I can’t tell who is who. I thought Usher was first but then the second verse came. I had an idea who that was, but then the 3rd verse came and I got all confused. Does anyone know? Please help me out.

WTF- WHO CHANGED THE FREAKINBEAT..
I STOPPED RIGHT THERE.

HIP/HOP IS OWNED BY WHITE MAN NOW PERIOD.

NO BLACK PERSON WOULD HAVE DONE THIS.

TIRED OF WATERED DOWN HIPHOP/

WHY CAN’T THESE ARTIST BE OROGINAL INSTEAD OF MESSIG UP SONGS THAT LASTED DECADE FOR EXAMPLE

WE ARE THE WORLD REMAKE’ WORST EVER!!!

NOW THIS.. EVERY THING DON’T NEED TO BE MADE FOR THE CLUB.. THAT IS WRONG WITH THEM SINGLE BUMS IN THE FIRST PLACE.

Since Q found Tevin is probably said he wouldn’t let it go without Tevin or Jermaine brought Tevin in so Q would be happy about the remix.

That damn Robin Thicke is nothing but another Elvis playing up to blacks while ripping off their talent to make millions for himself, black people loves getting played, always jumping up and down for whites thats stealing their own music, acting like a bunch of cheer leaders.

sigh……it’s ok but something is missing…is this the final mix

That remake to me is fire… Tevin sound so much like Michael Jackson. He has a beautiful voice. Jermaine did this one and it’s nice.

they did this simply for the strip clubs…. cuz ain’t no damn way….lol… no damn way people gonna be bumpin this!….
guess they will play this when the strip club is gettin ready to close

Sounds ok, that is Jermaine Dupri’s signature beat. Go back and listen to Ghost Town DJ’s , Enoy, etc..so predictable.

Shiiiiitt…Tevin jammed the hell out the joint! I actually think he should have done the whole song solo.

UGGGHHHHHHHH I’ma DIE! No, first I’ma throw up…THEN I’ma die.

I could have let it live vocally, but that beat is ain’t hittin on nothing. I’ma have to give this one a thumbs down.

Sounds good!

I like it with the tempo and all.

I like the original better even tho I never knew the name of the song until know. If they took that electric or whtever kind of music it is out it would’ve sounded good because they all sounded good.

There was some “pitchiness” in there.

This sounds like Secret Garden mixed with Ghost Town DJ’s My Boo

This is one time, I’ll say the actually did a good job in keeping a song alive, in a different way. I actually think it’s a great spin. I’ve heard silk redo it, and it sounds horrible…My dude Tevin YESSSSSSSSSS!!!! Do it TEV come back!!!! I love the original, hands down, but this is a cute rendition.

good or bad…none of them can top barry white,el debarge, al b sure and james ingram(ok maybe al b sure, lol)…and by the way…tevin campbell is a beast with the vocals…forget what ya’ll talking about!

WTF!!!

….doesn’t come m.e. where near the orig!!!!

IMO, this doesn’t hold a candle to the original, but it’s great to hear Tevin again! He was one of my favorite artists in the 90s.

not feelin it. some songs just shouldn’t be touched. NOBODY sings like those old school dudes. It’s like talent gets waeker decade after decade. Nobody’s messin with El, James and certainly not Barry…that’s probably why they kept Barry on the track! sorry guys, this is second rate. The beat aint doin nothing either. Bring back real music!

The original ” Secret Garden” did not need a remix and it did not need to be kept alive. Tevin sounds good but not like his old self. This song, did not do him justice but nevertheless, he sounds okay. The ATL beat did not go with this song—period. Maybe, if it had been a slower tempo with those Lil John’s 808s in that song he produced called ” Lovers and Friends” it would have been better but they just made a mess. It really was an immature move. Thanks.

I took a 2nd listen to the song and my conclusion is correct. The fellas, as brilliant as they are, they messed this song up. Ya’ll know it and go on and face it. I won’t tell, h.e.l.l. Tevin @ss sounds like he’s in the church choir singing to the deacon board. LOL—a mess.

It sounds good but the first one was the best!

Vocals are great, but production? Was Q asleep?

GOING to READ SOME BLACKNESS

w w w . t h e n o i r e f f e c t . c o m

why are yall hating? then all done very well, i love all three! Come back Tevin we miss you baby! and who cares if your gay…..i dont and wll support you!

UMMMMMPH! Whatever…. This is old & tired.

The beginning of this song was Usher (lead vocal until 2:35 & again around 3:45), the middle was Robin….Tevin only came in at the end (around 4:36)to do ad libs and falsetto sorta-runs….that was NOT a good display of Tevin’s vocals. So despite the failure of this remix’s tempo, Usher’s vocals sounded the best; as a matter of fact, it sounds like the song is Usher’s feat Robin & Tevin.

Too fast…it’s a turn off. C’mon son. No lady wants you running in her Secret Garden, slow it down, Fellas. LOL

USHER VOICE MAKES ME WEAK!!!!

I like it but all you need is Usher.

TEVIN STILL SOUNDS GREAT!!! ROBIN THICKE IS OKAY BUT HIS VOICE IS WEAK, HELL EVEN THE LAMEST BLACK GUY LIKE MARQUES HOUSTON SOUNDS BETTER THAN ROBIN IN MY OPINION-I’M SORRY. TEVIN SINGS BETTER THAN USHER-WOW!!!

BUT THIS IS NO WHERE NEAR AS GOOD AS THE ORIGINAL-AND THE BEST QUINCY COULD DO WAS DUB IN DEAD BARRY WHITE’S VOICE??? ACTUALLY I THINK I HEAR EL DEBARGE’S VOICE TOO? WTH, QUINCY?

HOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT HOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT HOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT BORTH SONGS ARE HOTTTTTTTTTTTTT USHER DO THIS SONG ALONE AND I GOT THAT ONE HOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT.