1st!!!

Guilty until proven innocent….I guess

wow, first???????oh, what a funny pic, but i think the sports fans @ ^^^^^^^sportinglove.com^^^^^^^ will like it. and be more interested in ur comments……..lololol

Just a very manly woman…very manly…a woman…but just…so…manly..

they’re all trannys. only a tranny would call herself “sasha fierce”.

@RE

You crazy…. LOL. That bish more manly than Jigga.

Black people are sooo damn ignorant. I am 100% certain that her gender would not be questioned if she were lighter than a brown paper bag. This is nothing more than typical black racism.

TOLD YA! People kill me…especially women. Hoping it was a man so they can find another reason to insult and emasculate black men (laughing at those who did find her attractive).

This should be a reminder to people that you should not believe everything you read…don’t be so gullible next time.

…see what I mean about ASSumptions…

..sadly…I agree Tiff…of course people will scoff and deny…

@Man

Lol, silly!

@Fashionista

Why should haters die? That’s extreme…

beyonce is that you

Anyway this music video is garbage_ just some publicity daddy Knowles planned it

really dont have an opinion bout it lol… waddup ppl.

WELL,IF ITS A MAN I MUST SAY HE PUTS MAKEUP ON BETTER THAN MOST WOMEN I KNOW!!!

The only thing that is good is the video, minus the song. I hate that song.

*yawn*

That make up is sooooo thick

It’s a woman for crying out oud leave her alone. Loooove beys top and jacket thats soo me well this looks like the new hair style so expect to see it for the next decade

That’s a damn man.

You guys need to leave them people alone! Beyonce, the dancers and the Choreographer.

This subject is all over the Net, and I have read some really hurtful, and mean comments made about these people from a bunch of strangers that do not know any of these people!!

This madness needs to stop! We are all entitled to our opinion, but my goodness!!

Nice to know that dark skinned women are still considered ugly and manly in our community. Did Michelle Obama pass your brown paper bag test?

IDK.. that still dont look like the “women” from the video???

@VoiceForReason

PREACH!!!

HI HATERS

THAT’S A DAMN MAN, YALL GUYS BETTER BE MORE CAREFUL U THINK U GOING TO BUST A NUT AND SHE BUSTS UR NUTS

What is this obsession with this dancer? it’s hard to tell a lot of women dancers are muscular!!

If it IS a dude, he was so nuff getting it in that video… and that’s all he/she had to do.

So why do you care?

some people have no integrity..

Honestly I wouldn’t be surprised if they both were men. Gay men have always been the best at j-setting that’s why schools usually hire gay men to teach the cheerleaders the j-setting moves. Anyways please retire this big hair era. This is not new. Aaliyah brought back the big bump in the front before she died. How long ago was that?

Dont yall know Beyonce dont like real competition…lol.She kicks out some pretty females in the group…etc..Latoya..Farrah and left with the fuglies.So she remained in the middle.Now she has men wit makeup in this video.smdh it figures..

THAT’S A DAMN MAN, YALL GUYS BETTER BE MORE CAREFUL U THINK U GOING TO BUST A NUT AND SHE BUSTS UR NUTS

___________________________________________________

Dead

Who said dark skin women are ugly???? Nobody. I am so tired of hearing that. Stop being so insecure… It is annoying that this is always brought up.

Looks like a man 2 me…I been thinking that since I seen the video…

this is still going on?

Voice of reason….

Who said she’s manly cause she’s dark? That doesn’t even make sense, and I’ve never heard people equate dark skinned to manly. That woman…erm…woman, has a very strong jaw and high cheek bones. Strong features are what we equate to being “manly” (and being muscular.

Furthermore, I’ve heard many a time that Tyra has tranny features, and clearly she’s not dark skinned.

She has a hard ass face! thats for sure.

Forget about the man stuff my question is why didn’t the lady tape down her side burns??? Those lamb chops are peasy

I don’t care if that’s a man or not. That hairstyle on all the women in that video is ugly ugly ugly ugly UGLY.

@This Whole Subject Is A Shame! wrote, “You guys need to leave them people alone! Beyonce, the dancers and the Choreographer.”

Can I beat down the choreographer for making a non-sensual azz-shaking video? It’s like watching can-can dancers, when my preference is belly dancers.

this is how you shake your body… presenting Sadie:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YamDoDK71Ds

I DONT UNDASTAND THE FASCINATION WITH “IS IT A TRANNY” WHO CARES! HE/SHE/IT DID THIER THING! YALL ACT LIKE HE OR SHE TRYING TO HAVE SEX WITH YALL OR SOMETHIN! GIVE THE GIRL OR GUY PROPS AND KEEP IT MOVIN! JEEZ!!!

@ Re

see, that’s the problem, almost everyone is missing the point:

why do you all of yall give a damn if its a woman or not?!?! it’s not that much of topic to begin with. If it’s a woman, let that woman be. If it’s a man, well hell, let that MAN be!!! it’s as simple as that. yall negroes are professional gossipers/haters….this is stupid….

I think its really sad that you needed to find something tohate on the video about so bad that you made one of the dancers being a man a big news story. SO WHAT!!! If it comes out that it is a man, is that gonna change the video? Will that mean he didn’t dance his ass off? Or are you just wishing it was a man so you can go into this “Beyonce’s so insecure she gets rid of all the retty girls” bull crap?

@Nita

Sadie is awesome…the weird thing is that she’s from Colorado (or Wissconsin)

@Nita

Sadie Shut It Down!!

She should have just put another thick yellow bone in there. We wouldn’t even be havin this discussion

The dark skinned young ladies man is Ebony and she is originally from Boston Ma where I live. Some folks here are very proud of her and she does have a cooch.

B*O*S*S*I*P,

With one hand you feed into the bias, prejudice, ignorance and hatred in our community and with the other you criticize those who perpetuate it. You talking out of both sides of your collective necks.

Hopefully with the Obama administration within our grasp, you will check yourselves and come forward with the integrity and forthrightness that you admire in him.

hey

I don’t really care about the woman/tranny but Bey doesn’t even look like herself in the pics from the video shoot….

LOL NYC!!! BEYONCE DOESNT EVEN LOOK LIKE HERSELF BECAUSE THATS NOT BEYONCE!!! BEYONCE IS NOWHERE IN THOSE PICS FROM THE VIDEO SHOOT….THE GIRL U THINK IS BEYONCE IS HER BACKUP DANCER ASHLEY!

Would we really be worried about this if she had lighter toned skin?? I’m just asking.

I HOPE IT IS A WOMAN.

THAT TRANNY MESS IS HORRIBLE!!! WE DON’T WANT THAT CRAP!!!

JUST LIKE WHEN TYRA TRIED TO PASS OFF THAT LIGHT SKINNED TRANNY ON TOP MODEL!!!!!!!

LIGHT SKIN, DARK SKIN, OR ANY SKIN…, NO TRANNYS!!!!!!

WE GOTTA DO BETTER IN THE UNITED STATES OBAMERICA!!!

OMG!! If I see one more post about someone being a tranny!! Last week it was Dawn (Danity Kane) now its the dancer from “Single Ladies,” find some better news!!

Truff , if you think we should do better, than why don’t you lead the way by dropping your bigotry?

BUT WHATS THE ISSUE IF IT IS A TRANNY? I MEAN MY GOODNESS …….THE PERSON OBVIOUSLY IS TALENTED!! WHAT TRANNYS ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO BE ON TV?? OR GET JOBS?? JEEZ! ARE YALL SO INSECURE THAT U THINK THE TRANNY WILL TAKE YOUR MAN?? OR LOOK BETTA DEN YOU? JEEZ GET OVER IT ITS NOT THAT DAMN IMPORTANT

YUK i just threw up thinking of the fact that it might be a dude eww. Why thats flithy

@ Re (MADVILLIANY…I heart DangerDoom)

C’mon now, let’s not play coy, we know how WE do. Let’s not act like we (meaning, YOU) aint never heard of OUR folks treatin the darker sisters like they’re less feminine, less attractive and all around less pleasant to be around. Darker sisters are portrayed as more loud, aggressive, disagreeable and more ghetto in general, but you already know this, I’m not going to break it down any further. Even I know this, and I’m light skinned.

The bigger shame is that we are more offended by a SISTER (and yes, let’s not forget that she is our SISTER) looking like a man, than if there were ACTUALLY a black man in the video dancing and prancing around as a woman. If Beyonce just came out and was like, yeah, I got a drag queen in my video, half of you wack sisters, would be shouting ‘go head girl’ and what not right along with the gay friend you know you got right next to you at this very moment. But an actual woman, with masculine features? Oh HELL NO, she got to go! Unacceptable!!

I got 2 words Venus and Serena

WTF? There is a HUGE deal if it is a tranny. Y’all are getting too damn comfortable with this whole ‘gay’ thing. Being gay is straight up WRONG! If you think there is no big deal with a Tranny dancing in a video next to Beyonce then you need Jesus.

the writer of this post is more suspect than the dancer

Seems like I was right all along. And I am going to repeat this one last time and leave it at that.

THIS WOULD NOT EVEN BE A DISCUSSION IF SHE WERE LIGHT SKINNED.

Well concidering it’s not my video, I’m not the one paying any of them…. I really don’t care.

T.I. said it best. **Live Your Life**

Damn people! Cut out the light/dark skin BS! If she is a woman she is simply a manly-looking woman. If she were light-skinned with the exact same facial features she would be a manly looking light-skin girl and ugly just the same. Try to judge exterior beauty by the person’s facial features not their complexion. Yes, black is beautiful but some people just aren’t cute…

She can dance nontheless. That’s what she was put in the video for and she did her job!

@ N,

But if she was light with the same features THIS WOULD NOT BE A DISCUSSION. Its a double standard.

Wow, and the media done splashed this woman’s picture all over the internet saying she had a dingaling and everything. I even heard it being reported on one of the local radio stations here in D.C. I feel bad for that poor person. If she is a man however, kudos to her because these sites are sure keeping her name in their mouths.

anthony you are ignorant. thats all ur opinion is. ignorance.

Just to set the record straight, she is woman! I know her personally, and it a shame that people would try to defame her character,she has strong beautful features, along with her beauty, she is a success and talent black women, who has paid her dues.Most importantly she the badiest dancer in the video maybe that’s what the whoop la is all about. FYI: These pictures are horrible and are a discrace to how she really looks.

you can trust and that you be seeing a lot more of her….

I still thinks its a dude

Well janet2gees, I can tell by your screen name your way of thinking. I don’t recall seeing your name (janet2gees on any movie sub tittles or videos. I don’t have to think or try to convince I know, Your trying to find out Nosey. Ps. Mizz or Mr. 2gees I bet she made more than that doing the video…

Prince dresses up like a woman and performs as his alter ego Rihanna. Doesnt anyone care about that ?

Both of those people are men. They are built narrow like men, no hips, no fat on the thighs. The lighter one just got some cheek work to make its face softer/rounder.

@ richie

Truff , if you think we should do better, than why don’t you lead the way by dropping your bigotry?

===================================================

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE TRANNYS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE CHILD MOLESTERS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE PIMPS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE POLYGOMISTS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE DOWN-LOW BOYS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE RAPISTS!

I AM NOT A BIGOT IF I DON’T LIKE SICK MESS!!!!!!!

Yau’ll Mofo’s always talking bout only dark girls get accused of being tranny…Ask Wendy Williams every body and they momma call her radio host tranny. And all dark skin girls are not created equal. A stunning dark skin girl would not get anything but lusted after such as when Tyrese had Maia Campbell as the lead in his sweet lady video.

Just because someone is ugly and they happen to have a dark complexion does not mean every dark girl is ugly. The Gabrielle Unions, Tatiana Ali’s, Carla Campbell’s and even Lola Love get so much attention its ridiculous. Stop the madness people.

@ Mr. FAMU

Seems like I was right all along. And I am going to repeat this one last time and leave it at that.

THIS WOULD NOT EVEN BE A DISCUSSION IF SHE WERE LIGHT SKINNED.

===================================================

YOU ARE WRONG!!!!!!! DEAD WRONG!!!!!!!!!

BECAUSE IT WAS AN ISSUE WHEN TYRA TRIED TO PASS OFF THAT “LIGHT SKIN” TRANNY ON TOP MODEL!!!!!!!!

GET YOUR STUFF “STRAIGHT”!!!

IT’S NOT A SKIN TONE THING! IT’S A TRANNY THANG!!!

aint no body think to look up this girl up myspace she on my list ashely i got her on it cause im a big fan of beyonce. now you see that man thing is man see how skinny in that pic with the pretty light skin ashely dancer? and yes ashely is mix her mother is black and her dad is white see how that makes beautyful kids with black women and white men?

that man thing is ugly as hell and the weave and make up did not save that black man at all. point black men are ugly ass women. please dont be gay and dress as a woman your faces are to manly! and ugly. yall aint got no soft face like asian men and mexican men. they are the ones who look more softer in the face i hate to say it. but black men white men are manly ruff looking when they put on a wig or weave. be a got damn man

As a dark-skinned black woman, I can say with confidence that

THIS IS NOT A MATTER OF SKIN COLOR!

some other issues are. this is not. that girl (?) looks very manly. her features are rough. maybe the hairstyle or makeup doesn’t suit her or something. whatever. but just straight up, the girl looks manly.

the end.

FOR REAL… THAT IS A SHEM.. ..NO MATTER SHEM SKIN COLOR AND “BIRTH RECORDS” IT IS A SHEM…LOOKS LIKE ANY OTHER SHEM ON SOUTH BEACH…AND SHEM IS A FIERCE DANCER ? ???SHEM INDEED.

The two WOMEN in this video names are

Vanessa Kenan

Anastasia Vertrais

and STFW if it is a dude. Most of the dudes watchin were probably thinkin to themselves shorty got a phatty. lol….well thats WTF you get for havin a dirty thought. Regardless of what like most have already said all 3 of them were gettin it. Stop hatin and do somethin with UR life cause obviously he or she did what they had to do to be dancin side by side with Mrs. Carter. CHUUUUUURCH!!!

wow…im speechless. btw there is Bee and her hubby I mean dude is carrying her bag…I thought he was justa bodyguard??? Isn’t her cousin her assistant??? Oh well, get em Sasha Fierce..

@ MO YOU GOT THE GIRLS NAME WRONG I KNOW FOR A FACT THE LIGHT SKINNED GIRLS NAMES IS ASHLEY EVERIT!! SHE’S BEEN DANCIN WITH BEYONCE SINCE HER B-DAY CD!!….AND SECONDLY WHETHER OR NOT BEING A TRANSEXUAL IS NORMAL OR ABNORMAL IS NOT THE ISSUE..THE ISSUE IS PASSING JUDGEMENT….CLEAN YOUR OWN LIFE UP B4 U JUDGE SOMEONE ELSE!!

WHo cares if that is a man or woman. She danced her ass off.

Being that this is all over the net I am sure she is aware of the gossip. How sad. Her career may be over all because of tabloid rumors.

if it is a man/woman/trans whatever, SHE killed it, she danced the BEST in the video. it was good to see some BROWN skin for a change!! i get tired of all these bright/light/latinas that dominate!!

Obviously it is a former man, just because it’s not the man in question. That tranny on ANTM looked more like a girl then this dude/lady!

@Voice of Reason

Everything you’ve said is correct. BUT- the issue here is that she has strong features, which ultimately people equate to masculinity. I’m sure you and I know of plenty of light-skinned women who are very strong-faced. Heck, Jada Pinkett has her tranny days, but she has a small face nonetheless (therefore you hear mixed reviews on her physical attributes).

And I have yet to say, “You go girl!” to a man wearing womens clothes, by the way. Sorry but men should stay men, and women should stay women, in my opinion.

THATS WHY THE WORLD SO TWISTED AND CONFUSED NOWA DAYS.YALL PRAISIN AND APPLAUDING TRANNIES AND HOMO’S.GETCHA MIND RIGHT.AINT NOTHING COOL ABOUT THAT.IF IT WAS,GOD WOULDNT HAVE DESTROYED SADOM AND GAUMORA. BURN OUT HYPOCRITES AND SODOMITES

I say MAN, mostly because of the sideburns and Veiny forearms and hands. If im right, good 4 him, cuz ya boy got a mean tuck game.

Ditto Re…if it werent for the tig ol bitties, people would question Ty Ty, Tyra. Ciara isnt dark either. How did skin color get in this post?

BURN OUT FUNNY MAN AND SODOMITES

damn if i was her id feel real salty having all these gossip sites try and figure out whether or not im a man or a woman. let the girl be. she isnt doing anything to you.

WHY DO IT LOOK LIKE OL’ GIRL IS PLAYING WITH DUDES BUTTIE, WITH THAT GRINCH SMILE.

Hell! I was watching the tranny more than Beyonce. Shim killed it in that video. Not good when your back up dancer out shines you. Lol…

Um that is a man no doubt…not that I am against it…you got workk it! But that is a man. Her/his facial structure is very strong and I have never seen a woman (other than body builders) with their veins in their arms potruding like her/his!

I was happy to see a darker skinned female in a video, too, but I was disappointed (the one time I think they actually show her face) to see that she wasn’t pretty like the other two, though not ugly…but then I wondered if she was a man because she her features are strong and she’s veiny and muscled up…Beyonce and the other girl aren’t all muscled up like that yet they’re all about the same size. All that muscle just looks weird on a girl.

If Bey wants to use two trannies in her video who are dancing their a$$es off – SO FCUKING WHAT!!!!!

That girl the one everyone claims to be a tranny must be upset and pissed as hell everyone is calling her a man i would be mad lol

*She works out, and is dark skinned so she’s a dude? I guess Venus Williams is too. If you notice in the pic with the dancers together the “tranny” isn’t wearing a bra, yet her breasts have a natural shape. Not stiff, and perfectly round like implants. That’s no man, but lets not act like it’s obvious when a woman’s not really a woman. If anything it’s the contrary. Look up Maury “Man, or Woman” episodes, and Chen Lili.