Johnson has said that she and Griner agreed to have the girls, and Johnson got pregnant via a sperm donor at a fertility clinic.
The paternity question is a huge issue for Griner. If Johnson’s old boyfriend fathered the babies, it could get her off the hook from paying child support.
The exes married in May 2015, just weeks after cops arrested them for a violent fight in their suburban Phoenix, Az. home. The couple announced Johnson was pregnant in June, with Griner filing to annul the marriage the next day.
We’ve reached out to both Griner and Johnson’s lawyers.
UPDATE: Griner’s lawyer told us that they were able to work things out with Johnson and obtained her medical records despite the judge’s order.